Historical Fictionistas discussion
Group Read Discussions
>
August 2013: HF Nominations
date
newest »


please!"
Looks like this one is considered a Classic and not HF. It was first published in 1900.

I've been wanting to read that one!

Oh good, I've been waiting for an excuse to pull this out of the stack and read it.

Then I would be excited to discuss
Pompeii by Robert Harris.
Feel like rereading it again, this time missing not one single detail :)


please!"
Looks like this one is considered a Classic and not HF. It was first published in 1900."
I thought Historical Fiction included Classics? What is the difference? I am not challenging, just curious :)!

I guess it's arguable if this is "historical" or not, and if the group deems it not so then I'll change my nomination. We haven't read anything about ancient times in a while, and I just started this book recently. I wouldn't mind discussing it.

It depends on the publication date. In this group, we use the definition that the setting of the work needs to be at least 50 years before the publication date. So if My Antonia written in 1900 had a setting of 1850 or say 1825 then it would be considered both a classic and HF. But, I checked wiki and it didn't look that way. If there's proof otherwise, I'm willing to count it as nomination.

It depends on the publication date. In this group, we use the defin..."
The descriptions I'm reading about it say it was first published in 1918. I never trust GR's first publication dates on old books, they're often wrong. On Amazon, it says "First published in 1918, and set in Nebraska in the late 19th century". But even so, it would have to be set before 1868 to count and I'm not sure I'd consider that the LATE 19th century, more like the mid 19th century.


Fun summer read, but good luck finding it; this series is for hoarders."
I'm going to say no to this nomination then. There is no point in having a group read people can't get their hands on. :)
Would you like to nominate something else?


Fun summer read, but good luck finding it; this series is for hoarders."
I'm going to say no to this nomination then. There is no point in having a group ..."
Sorry! You're right, but if you get a chance to pick one up, do it! Ignore the trashy covers, the series is great fun. And they're selling for a small fortune on ebay and Amazon.
How about The Shoemaker's Wife by Adriana Trigiani?


This sounds absolutely amazing. Such an unusual story and location. I'm going to buy it anyway.


Kathleen, The Shoemaker's Wife was our January read. Good book, though.

Hi Tony. Yes I am from India. no sorry I have not read the book, but have you by chance read the works of Amitav Ghosh? His Iblis Trilogy would fall under historical fiction I suppose (its on the opium trade during the 19th century)


Are you thinking of Jasmine?
Books mentioned in this topic
Jasmine (other topics)The Aviator's Wife (other topics)
The Last of the Wine (other topics)
The Shoemaker's Wife (other topics)
The Bronze Horseman (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Mary Renault (other topics)Adriana Trigiani (other topics)
Anne Golon (other topics)
Michelle Moran (other topics)
Philippa Gregory (other topics)
More...
Source
Theme: In honor of Book Lovers Day let’s celebrate by sharing our love of reading. This one is a freebie, so feel free to nominate any HF book you feel like reading.
Rules for Nominating:
* ONE nomination per member
*There is no need to second or third a nomination
*AUTHORS- Before you nominate your book please read our Group rules
*Do not nominate books the group already has read. To check for previous group reads check the group's bookshelf: http://www.goodreads.com/group/booksh...
* LINK the title and book you are nominating. If you cannot link please include the title and author in your nomination. If there is no author included in your nomination I will not accept it.
Example: Helen's Daughter by Laura Gill
-or-
Helen’s Daughter by Laura Gill are both acceptable.
The nomination thread will run until July 4th. I will then put up the poll which will run until July 8th.
Thank you!