The Sword and Laser discussion
What Else Are You Reading?
>
Urban Fantasy Where to Start?

Ben Aaaronovitch writes about a London policeman who is also a wizard - perhaps similar to Jim Butcher's Dresden Files, although for my money much better written.



But I guess American Gods comes closer to what you are looking for.

Alex wrote: " I don't suppose anyone's written a book set in a coffee shop where the events that writer writes about while there start to come to true and he and the barista have to team up to stop the cult posing as cupcake shop next door from awakening cuthulu from beneath the city?"
For some reason this reminded me of a graphic novel I read a while back. Not quite the same, but cute. I'll link below. :D


The first is a story about a secret society, where the members can pull items out of story pages, the second is an Avoid-the-Apocalypse story based on celtic mythology.

As Ruth said, the Dresden Files violates most of what you asked for but is also probably the series you want to read. It starts off okay and becomes really really good by about book 3 or 4.
On that note, Zero Sight is also very good, despite the vampire.

I'll second Neverwhere by Gaiman, and the Dresden Files, but Dresden does have vampires and werewolves and fairies and the kitchen sink. But they are great, especially the audio versions.




You know what, now that you mention it, I actually do know of a book like that:
Whispers - Book One - Yggdrasil Children
This one comes with some caveats...
First and foremost, I know the author. He's a great guy, he's been writing and revising the story for like 5 years, but it's a grain of salt that you should probably hold on to.
Secondly, I last read this one when it was in early alpha (read: almost painfully rough), but that was a couple years ago and I'm sure it has improved since then. Which reminds me that I should read and review it soon...
Finally, this is a first book written by an indie author, and if you find the idea of debut or independently published novels frightening then this one is probably not for you. Then again, finding non-mainstream urban fantasy probably means you're looking for something off the beaten path, and that is where a lot of the indies hang out. It also means that the book is cheap, in case that's a factor.
Now (since I'm a bad friend) I haven't gotten around to reading this final version of the book yet, and I'm not a fan of blindly recommending things. However, from a strictly content-based point of view, I believe this book satisfies all of your criteria.
Except for the coffee shop thing. Everyone knows that Lovecraftian horrors from the beyond fthagen beneath football fields, and that it's the frozen yogurt shops that are part of a plot to awaken them. Cupcakes, honestly.

I'm probably splitting hairs here, but you didn't specifically forbid faeries, so I'll mention Seanan McGuire's October Daye books, starting with Rosemary and Rue. It is superficially similar to a lot of the other paranormal detective books out there, but Toby Daye isn't a 20-something stumbling into a supernatural world--part of that is her backstory, but she's well into her 30s with an estranged husband and daughter.
Here are a few more I haven't read myself but from what I've heard they might be what you're looking for:
The Monster Hunter International series
Kraken by China Miéville
The Shambling Guide to New York City by Mur Lafferty

I always highly recommend Dresden Files to everyone, but if you want something more off the the beaten path that's quick and not very deep, I rather enjoyed the Nightside books starting with Something from the Nightside.
They were mostly 3 star books for me, but they are usually pretty fun and I don't remember any vampires or werewolves, but it's been awhile.
They were mostly 3 star books for me, but they are usually pretty fun and I don't remember any vampires or werewolves, but it's been awhile.

I followed it up with 'Last Call': also very good. And ended up reading all his work. 'Declare' is still the best for me, but as you are starting in this genre..I think you would benefit most from starting with his early works...

(Have you watched Steins;Gate? It's an anime I think you might enjoy.)
You might like Snow Crash.... Also, I second the recommendation of Charles Stross's Laundry files. It's got spy agencies and Lovecraftian horror.

Love Geekomancy. Michael Underwood needs a paper pub deal instead of E Only
Dresden is obvious right? :)
Libriomancy is great
Love Kevin Hearne's Iron Druid Chronicle's just roll your eyes past some of the sillier parts and keep reading cuz the characters are great.
London Falling by Paul Cornell sounds a little closer to your description although I'm only about a third through and not really loving it yet. Helps to be very up on your Brit speak too:)




A lot of people have mentioned the dresden files but its not a series I've ever thought to try probably because I caught a bit of an episode of tv series once and didn't like it. Is it the kind of series you should start at the beginning or can I jump in anywhere?
I have to stay though London seems to be the go to urban paranormal city. And I have to ask what is with all the cheesy descriptions on these books? I had to laugh after reading a few of them.
Libriomancer sounds like it could be interesting even if it does have vampire. The premise reminds a bit of some books I read by Jasper Fforde. He did a series of humorous books with the lead character is a literary detective Thursday Next. A woman who can travel in and out of fiction. The first one has her tracking down Jayne Eyre's kidnapper.

In fact my unsuccessful :-( entry into the S&L anthology was a cyberpunk short story.
I haven't seen Steins;Gate yet I'll give it a watch though. The premise reminds me a bit of Mirai Nikki an anime series about the god of time giving 12 people cell phones that contain entries in their blog/twitter about the future. And then tells them that the universe will end in 90 days unless they battle to death and the sole survivor becomes the new god of time.

Neil Gaiman's Neverwhere. For me this pretty much embodies the definition of Urban Fantasy. The setting (London) is integral to the plot and as much a character as the protagonist is.
Chuck Wendig'sBlackbirds. Grim and seedy. One woman and her special ability to see the time and place of the death of everyone she touches, against, well, herself mostly, but also a pair of hired tugs and a crime boss. I personally call things like this "contemporary fantasy" or a paranormal thriller maybe even but the book has "file under: Urban Fantasy" printed on the back, so there's that.
Dan Well's I Am Not A Serial Killer
John Wayne Cleaver is diagnosed with "clinical sociopathy" and is worried about the (very real) possibility that he might become a serial killer. So he builds barriers around his inner monster in an attempt to be as normal as possible. Then an actual serial killer starts killing in his hometown and our "hero" decides to go after him. Of course things get complicated when John finds out that the serial killer is actually a demon, and that he has trouble containing his own inner demon now he has let him out for the hunt. The way the author places you into the mind of a sociopath is really uncanny IMO.
Lauren Beukes' The Shining Girls
Continuing with our supernatural serial killer theme: All throughout the 20e century promising young women turn up brutally butchered. During the 90's one of the victims however narrowly survives the attempt on her life, scarred for life, both physically and emotionally, she's unable to let go and starts to track down her would be murdered. Things get surreal when she begins to suspect that a 100 years worth of murders might all be committed by the same man.

Please don't let a glimpse at the Dresden Files tv show put you off the books! The books are far superior whereas, in my opinion, the tv show completely screwed the pooch!

Completely agreed. The TV show was dreadful. The books (what I've read so far, and I intend to read more) are great!

So for instance some of the Fritz lieber gray mouser stories are "urban" fantasy where as others are not. As such there is huge diversity as to what books you might or might not be interested in.
If you take say the Lauren Hamilton and the Sookie Stackhouse novels they share 99% of their DVD although much of the action in the sookie stories has a more rural setting.
Nights of Villjamur is a great series of books set in a city (i have only read the first one). It is literate, epic and a lot of fun. I cannot think of a book or series to compare it to which is a strength in itself
China Mieville often has an urban setting whether in his superb YA Un Lun Dun, in his excellent crime/Fantasy crossover The City and the City or most of his other work. I think that there are some other authors who write more interesting characters but his books are very much worth checking out.
Jeffrey Ford's Well-built City series (at least the first 2 count) is really creative and interesting. Think one part wierd, one part gene Wolfe...
Speaking of Gene Wolfe - his Book of the Long Sun series is mainly set (first volume anyway) with an urban setting and is an enjoyable story with layers and layers buried beneath the surface adding more and more to it as pieces start fitting together.
Graham Joyce and Liz Jensen are two authors who write contemporary fantasy that isnt full of vampires etc. The setting is not always "urban" but they are consistently worth looking for.
I am currently reading House of Leaves which could be classed as an urban fantasy (it can be seen as a haunted house story). Its a pretty heafy book to be carrying around for a commute but it is really a lot of fun once you get your head around it and the story gets going.
Caitlin Kiernan writes really interesting dark fantasy stuff like The Drowning Girl that would be worth checking out.
I see some others have recommended - Tim Powers - I have been meaning to give him a try. Although there are vampires in Libromancer it is a lot of fun and it does not feel like a "vampire" book.

In regards to your question, which I feel has been covered very well by the other posters, I would like to suggest the 20 palaces series by Harry Connolly. These novels we're very much under appreciated and deserved more recognition, and while the series was officially cancelled the books are still worth reading.
I didn't hate the show, but it wasn't great. It's responsible for me discovering the series though.


I have to second Rob's recommendation about the Nightside series by Simon R. Green. It's "lighter" UF than the Dresden files, somewhat tongue-in-cheek, but it also is set largely in a world that resembles Neil Gaiman's Neverwhere. For a different spin, also try Snake Agent by Liz Williams, which is UF with an asian setting. All that being said, I'm also a huge Dresden fan...

I also discovered the novels through the TV series. It was kind of silly and campy, but it was an enjoyable show and I didn't have the books to compare it to at the time.
I would also like to second the previous mention of The Dirty Streets of Heaven. Great book, and the second in the series just came out not too long ago.

[From Wikipedia] In a forum post Jim Butcher stated "The show is not the books. It is not meant to follow the same story. It is meant as an alternate world, where the overall background and story-world is similar, but not all the same things happen. The show is not attempting to recreate the books on a chapter-by-chapter or even story-by-story basis." continuing by saying that viewers should not expect a duplicate of the books, and those expecting it would be disappointed.

I'm surprised you haven't tried Gaiman's The Sandman, Vol. 1: Preludes and Nocturnes graphic novels yet. Given the things you say you like, I'd be stunned if you didn't like them. "Ya so anything like those would be good. Mystery, playing with reality, some time warping stuff, and cults/secret societies." -- there's probably all of that in first 30 pages of the first comic ... and Gaiman says that he didn't even hit his stride until a full volume in.
Also, you stopped at the right time on WoT. If you think you're tired of Aes Sedai now, the next 5 books will make you homicidal.

Kate Griffin.
Kate Griffin is the name under with Catherine Webb writes urban fantasy, set in London (which is where Urban Fantasy must begin). The first four books by Griffin set in her UF locale center on Matthew Swift, a sorcerer who finds himself reliant upon the magic of London to again and again fight back ... everything, including the bureaucracy.
Reviews to her books are available at Fantasy Book Review (.co.uk) and below;
Maybe the prototypical Urban Fantasy is Neil Gaiman's , and that's a good place to start too.
There are other authors - and spring to mind, but both write middling-to-good stories.
The best new urban fantasy would have to be , which is definitely an impressive debut.
Yeah, I review books for a 'living'. :)


Would also add stories set in the shared world Borderland
Anthologies:
Borderland, edited by Terri Windling and Mark Alan Arnold (1986)
Bordertown, edited by Terri Windling and Mark Alan Arnold (1986)
Life on the Border, edited by Terri Windling (1991)
The Essential Bordertown edited by Terri Windling and Delia Sherman (1998)
Welcome to Bordertown, edited by Holly Black and Ellen Kushner (2011)
Novels:
Elsewhere, Will Shetterly (1991)
Nevernever, Will Shetterly (1993)
Finder, Emma Bull (1994)

I love this book but its not for the faint of heart as its IMMENSE. Can't say for sure but it might well be the longest by far book I've ever read. My version is 1300 pages of the most densely packed print per page I've ever seen. One page of this book has as many words as 3-4 pages of most books.

Caveat though to potential Dresden Files readers. The first few books are Butcher's first published novels and aren't really that good. Its not until book three or four where it finally starts clicking for him and the series hits high gear. Someone gave me this advice a year or two ago when I was struggling with the first books and I'm glad I took it because from the third to fourth book on I loved it.


Everything changes when Quentin finds himself unexpectedly admitted to a very secret, very exclusive college of magic in upstate New York, where he receives a thorough and rigorous education in the practice of modern sorcery. He also discovers all the other things people learn in college: friendship, love, sex, booze, and boredom.
An interesting take on urban fantasy (no detectives, vampires, werewolves, dark conspiracies etc), but it does fit into the broader definition of the genre.

I just finished The Magicians and found it to be one of the most tedious unenjoyable experiences I've ever had in books. I did it via audio book and had I not basically been a captive audience in an across Nevada and back road trip I would have surely lemmed it.
Its like Harry Potter meets Narnia only without any of the fun, likeable characters, or enjoyable moments of those series. In fact, the main character Quentin is such a miserable little **** that I was hoping that he'd get eviscerated by the end.
Barring another captive audience situation I can't imagine ever going back to this series.

MM9 is about kaiju, but it has a very interesting view of how the universe works and how these giant monsters can exist. It's Urban Fantasy without elves.
Books mentioned in this topic
Distant Star (other topics)Bob Moore: No Hero (other topics)
Sandman Slim (other topics)
Detective Pat (other topics)
The Last Policeman (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Liz Williams (other topics)Simon R. Green (other topics)
Jasper Fforde (other topics)
Kim Harrison (other topics)
Ian Tregillis (other topics)
More...
So I'm thinking I'd give urban fantasy a try but have looked through few list it seems most urban fantasy books are paranormal romance novels and that is really not what I'm looking for. So I'm hoping for a little guidance.
What I don't want is a book about a 20 something girl who is living a dull life until she meets a mysterious stranger who leads to an exciting and dangerous world where she discovers she's been special all along. Blah blah. Also nothing with vampires, werewolves, witches, zombies, dwarves, or elves of any kind.
I know that seems to make it tough to find fantastical stories in modern times. But they must exist right?
The kinda of thing ideally I'd like is something similar to the persona 4 anime series where a serial killer is killing people by trapping them in a dark world that can be asked via any tv on a certain day. Once inside the victims have to battle their own demons or be destroyed by them. Or something like another persona game where a secret society uses an ancient power to cause rumors to become real and then starts manipulating information to sort their own ends. Or something like the manga series psyren where people are sent into a dark future where they discover a group has set the world on the path to destruction and those who survive to make back to the present must use the psychic powers they acquired to stop the group from carrying out their plan.
Ya so anything like those would be good. Mystery, playing with reality, some time warping stuff, and cults/secret societies. I don't suppose anyone's written a book set in a coffee shop where the events that writer writes about while there start to come to true and he and the barista have to team up to stop the cult posing as cupcake shop next door from awakening cuthulu from beneath the city?