ÀÏ»¢»úÎÈÓ®·½·¨

Always Pouting's Reviews > When Breath Becomes Air

When Breath Becomes Air by Paul Kalanithi
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
48650982
's review

really liked it

Paul Kalanithi is thirty six and so close to finishing his training as a neurosurgeon when he finds out he has stage IV lung cancer. As an undergraduate Kalanithi studied English literature and his love of reading and writing had been a constant through out his life. He had always felt that when he was older he would like to write and had decided to focus on neurosurgery for now, where he could make a bigger difference by saving people's lives. All his hopes and dreams for the future were suddenly unrealistic as an upper limit of a handful of years was put onto his life. Kalanithi pens this memoir, dealing with the struggles of facing death and having to go from being able to save others lives to now be the one staring down mortality.

The writing was excellent but reading this memoir was so depressing. Just the fact that someone so brilliant was going to die and not be able to keep contributing when they clearly had so much to offer. I was disappointed by where the book left off but then I read the afterword to find out that he had died before he could even finish the memoir which just made it twenty times worse. Death is inevitable but like Kalanithi acknowledges we don't really think about it as being imminent and so it's not the same as when you're terminal and trying to make peace with dying. I just found it so hard to read him struggling to make sense of how to best use the rest of his time especially since there was no way for him to know how limited it really was. Also the fact that he didn't get to see more of his daughter and watch her grow up. It was just depressing honestly, well written but I just felt sad and I don't know what else to say. It just feels unfair because I wish I was even a fraction as smart or eloquent but I'm not but I get to live and he doesnt.
142 likes ·  ∙ flag

Sign into ÀÏ»¢»úÎÈÓ®·½·¨ to see if any of your friends have read When Breath Becomes Air.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

June 4, 2017 – Started Reading
June 4, 2017 – Shelved
June 23, 2017 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-11 of 11 (11 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

Fragrant Flower Do you like it so far? 😉🙂


Always Pouting haven't started it!


message 3: by Selene (new)

Selene Such emotionally heavy content. Great review ;))


Always Pouting Selene wrote: "Such emotionally heavy content. Great review ;))"

Thanks! It was an emotional read but it was good I don't usually like memoirs much


Jennifer ~ TarHeelReader Beautiful review, PA! I've had this one here but keeping putting it off for the right time. Hopefully I'll make time to read it soon. :)


message 6: by Linda (new) - added it

Linda Oh, Pouting, you are such a love! This was a wonderful review, and we are all so happy that you are who you are--always honest, always reading, always sharing your feelings.


Always Pouting Linda wrote: "Oh, Pouting, you are such a love! This was a wonderful review, and we are all so happy that you are who you are--always honest, always reading, always sharing your feelings."

Jennifer ~ TarHeelReader wrote: "Beautiful review, PA! I've had this one here but keeping putting it off for the right time. Hopefully I'll make time to read it soon. :)"

Thanks guys, everyone on here is so sweet it makes me emotional but I just try to be honest because I love reading other people's reviews about how books made them feel so but this was one of the harder ones to read but it was pretty good, pretty heartbreaking about leaving a family behind especially when the memoir ends on him talking about his daughter


Lisa "It just feels unfair because I wish I was even a fraction as smart or eloquent but I'm not but I get to live and he doesnt." No! Your life isn't any less valuable. We all contribute, maybe not on the scale of Kalanithi, but in ways we don't even realize.


Always Pouting Lisa wrote: ""It just feels unfair because I wish I was even a fraction as smart or eloquent but I'm not but I get to live and he doesnt." No! Your life isn't any less valuable. We all contribute, maybe not on ..."

Thats so sweet Lisa ha ha I just envy people's intelligence sometimes


message 10: by Melissa (new)

Melissa Crytzer Fry Goodness -- this sounds like a tough one to get through.


Kathryn in FL What an awesome review, you capture the feelings of helpless as the situation unfolds. Though it was so depressing, it was also hopeful. This is in my top three favorite books. What a wonderful and humble man, I can't imagine what it must have been like to know him personally. To me that had to be the biggest issue. I lost a friend of similar personality, she died from cancer that she battled for over 12 years, in private she would tell me, that she had peace in just wanted to be free. She would then apologize for sharing this "burden". She had no idea how much I understood (my anger at her own intense pain) and I told her I didn't judge her...I still very much miss her even though I only knew her for a year (we had an instant connection) and that was more than 15 years ago.


back to top